Course 701 - Effective Safety Committee Operations

Safety guides and audits to make your job as a safety professional easier

Motivating Involvement

Introduction

Safety Committee
Motivation is a wonderful thing.

The safety committee should be composed of both managers and employees who understand its role, purposes, and activities and are interested in its success. It seems most companies experience varying degrees of difficulty generating enthusiasm for the safety committee. We'll look at the possible reasons for this, and then discuss some solutions.

Safety Committees Mean Involvement

Involving your employees in an activity such as a safety committee that directly affects their safety and health is the right thing to do. Below are reasons why it's also the smart thing to do. Click on the button to see some of the benefits of involvement in the safety committee.

  • Line workers are in frequent contact with potential safety and health hazards. They have a vested interest in effective protection programs.
  • Experience has demonstrated that line workers can be highly valuable problem-solvers.
  • Group decisions have the advantage of the group's wider field of experience.
  • Research shows that employees are more likely to support and use programs in which they have had input.
  • Employees encouraged to contribute their ideas, and those ideas are taken seriously are more satisfied and productive on the job.
  • Owners and managers have a solid grasp of the company’s overall operations. On the other hand, line workers probably have a more detailed knowledge of each operation and task at your worksite.
  • Employees who understand the hazards associated with workplace operations will realize that they have the most to gain from preventing or controlling exposure to those hazards. Knowledgeable and aware employees tend to be safe workers and good sources of ideas for better hazard prevention and control.

Perceptions Drive Reality

Many reasons might explain why both managers and employees have no interest in a safety committee. What drives that lack of interest? Click on the button to see a examples of the perceptions that might cause a lack of interest in the safety committee.

Perceptions that might cause a lack of interest in the safety committee include:

  • Why join the safety committee? Who cares?
  • Safety committee members are "volunteered" against their will;
  • Meetings are boring and a total waste of my time;
  • Safety committee members aren't properly trained;
  • Safety committee duties would cut into my busy schedules;
  • One person dominates all of the meetings;
  • The safety committee never gets anything done;
  • Safety committee meetings end up just being gripe sessions; and
  • The safety committee is just a pack of snitches.

1. Why might employees generally have no interest in being involved in a safety committee?

a. They don't feel smart enough
b. Negative perceptions about membership
c. Lack of adequate compensation
d. The lack of career advancement

Next Section

Gaining Credibility - Expert and Position Power

Safety Committee

By doing what they say they're going to do.

What does it mean to be credible? A quick look in the dictionary tells us that to be credible means "capable of being believed: deserving confidence."

What's the implied message here? Credibility must be earned!

So, the real question is, "What can the safety committee do to increase its credibility and earn confidence in its recommendations?"

To get things done, you must have credibility. To do that, safety committees must demonstrate expert power and position power.

Expert power

To be believable, members of the safety committee must clearly understand their role, purpose, duties, and responsibilities. They need to understand where their responsibility ends and where management's responsibility takes over.

When the safety committee realizes they play an internal consultant's role to the employer, they know that their credibility depends on the expertise they bring to the role. How do you gain expertise? By increasing your knowledge and gaining experience.

Writing and submitting effective recommendations to management is crucial to gain credibility. The most effective recommendations will discuss costs and benefits and offer reasonable options for correcting workplace hazards, unsafe work practices, and ineffective administrative controls.

Position Power

Another strategy for gaining credibility is to increase the committee's position power. A characteristic of position power is access to the decision-makers. Does the safety committee chairperson have access to the CEO?

Does the committee "have the ear" of the person in charge? A safety committee's position power is strengthened when it communicates with the head of the organization. Which safety committee has more position power: The committee reporting to the deputy director for human resources, or the committee reporting to the CEO? The principle here is that for the safety committee to increase its own position power, it must communicate directly with the powerful positions found within the organization.

2. Which two forms of power are necessary for the safety committee to gain credibility?

a. Expert and position power
b. Position and reward power
c. Control and coercive power
d. Charismatic and referent power

Next Section

Gaining Credibility - Communication

Safety Committee
Good communication is necessary to assure safety committee success.

Effective communication is key in establishing expert and position power.

When employees inform or make suggestions, they expect to get something done and feedback soon after that. They naturally want to see action. Suppose safety committee representatives take the information to the safety committee but neglect to give management and employees feedback. What is management going to think about the safety committee?

Therefore, to gain credibility with managers and employees, communicate regularly and often with them. If a hazard can't be fixed for a while, let people know why. They will appreciate it, even if it's not the answer they want to hear. The safety committee has done its job.

Another good idea is to appropriately "brag" about safety committee accomplishments. I don't mean that the committee members should go out and literally brag about how great they are. Just let employees know about safety committee accomplishments and do so with some excitement and pride.

Employees see the safety committee as a communications conduit to management.

3. What is necessary for safety committees to gain credibility with employees?

a. Top management awareness
b. Safety committee meetings
c. Regular communication
d. Consistent enforcement

Next Section

Apathy

Safety Committee
How do you overcome safety committee apathy?

Apathy in and towards the safety committee is common in some companies. There may be many reasons, but this problem is usually due to factors that can be influenced by the safety committee and top management.

Lack of commitment by top management is likely the most common complaint given by safety committee members for a lack of accomplishment that fosters apathy. But, are safety committees premature in "blaming" management for all their ills?

It's good to remember that when you've got the finger of blame pointed outward, three other fingers are pointing inward. Safety committee members may want to first reflect on how well they are fulfilling their own responsibilities before accusing management for lack of success.

As we mentioned in Module 1, safety committees must have a clear vision to succeed. Management, as well, must have a vision for safety. Safety committees can help management gain that vision by "educating up" - giving management information about successful safety committees' benefits.

Another less common but important reason safety committees fail is because meetings are too long and boring. Watch the video to get some good ideas on improving the quality of safety committee meetings.

If safety committees suffer from a lack of involvement, ways to turn that situation around include:

  • Get management agreement to provide incentives like recognition, rewards, training, bonuses, and career progression to motivate employees to volunteer as committee members.
  • Make sure safety committee meetings are short - no longer than one hour. Provide refreshments like pizza, pastries, or coffee.
  • Communicate safety committee accomplishments to the workforce.

4. What is the most common complaint safety committees give for their failure to be effective?

a. Lack of top management commitment
b. Low employee participation
c. Lack of control of safety
d. No one cares, so why bother

Next Section

Motivation

Safety Committee
A little positive recognition goes a long way!

It goes without saying that the most successful safety committees are composed of volunteers. It’s better to get someone to do something because they want to be involved, not because they have to be involved.

Suppose employees know why membership is important or contributes to their own and their company's success. In that case, they are more likely to be a motivated volunteer!

However, when employees are not interested in committee membership, management may use the "carrot and stick" strategy to do something about it.

  • Positive Consequences (the carrot). Management might try to motivate employees using positive recognition and reward if they volunteer for membership (the carrot). This is the most effective motivational strategy. Employees will actively participate in the committee.
  • Negative Consequences (the stick). Management might use some form of intimidation or coercion to get employees to "volunteer" themselves. This strategy is successful only to achieve compliance. Employees will show up to committee meetings, but that’s about it.

So, how can management best use positive consequences to motivate employee involvement in the safety committee?

5. How does management best ensure a long-term all-volunteer safety committee?

a. Rotate membership in committees
b. Recognize and reward those who volunteer
c. Require membership in committees
d. Reprimand those who do not volunteer

Next Section

Management Support and Commitment

Safety Committee

Management demonstrates serious commitment when they give safety serious time and money.

Management demonstrates support through communication and commitment through action. Support is shown by saying that the safety committee is important. However, commitment is demonstrated through action, for example, by investing time and money into the safety committee.

Support. How is support expressed?

  • Formally through the mission statement, policies, job descriptions, and performance appraisals.
  • Informally through word of mouth; a simple recognition of a job well done or appreciation expressed before a group of peers.

Commitment: Commitment is more than an expression of support. It is achieved by investing serious time and money in the safety committee. A few examples include:

  • allowing members of the safety committee more than an hour a month to work their safety responsibilities;
  • promoting those who serve on safety committees because they have increased knowledge and skills in safety and health management;
  • responding to the recommendations made to correct conditions, practices, and systems;
  • through active membership in the committee; and
  • by attending (as observers) safety committee meetings from time to time.

6. How is a commitment to the safety committee different than mere support?

a. It allows committees to be composed of many employees
b. It involves attendance at meetings by managers
c. It requires serious time and money
d. It includes regular positive communication

Next Section

How Management Encourages Volunteers

Safety Committee
Think of involvement in the safety committee as a management apprenticeship program.

How can management best encourage employees to volunteer to become safety committee members? Management must answer an important employee question, "what's in it for me?"

Reward members of the safety committee with tangible and intangible incentives.

  • Tangible rewards are most commonly those that have a financial value of some kind. They might consist of promotions, merit pay increases, or bonuses.
  • Intangible rewards include public recognition and increased status. Examples might be recognition on performance appraisals, accreditation as a safety professional, or just being thanked for doing a good job.

Management can let it be known that it is an employee's advantage for career advancement to gain experience on the safety committee. After all, doesn't a member of the safety committee gain additional professional communications skills, meeting management, problem-solving, occupational safety and health programs, hazard identification, accident investigation, recommendation writing, and other areas?

That's quite a list. Consequently, safety committee membership should make an employee more qualified for advancement. Think of involvement in the safety committee as part of a "management apprenticeship" program.

7. Which of the following is an example of a tangible reward that might be important to safety committee members?

a. Remarks in a performance appraisal
b. A merit pay increase
c. Increased status among employees
d. Recognition by the supervisor

Next Section

Proactive Recognition Programs

Safety Committee

Hey, pizza works for me! Be sure to thank everyone for coming and participating too.

Here are a few ideas for developing a proactive safety recognition program rewarding and recognizing performance to prevent injuries in your company:

Safety Buck: Supervisors carry safety bucks, and when they see employees doing something right, they reward them. Employees can take the safety buck to the company cafeteria for lunch or use it at a local participating store to purchase items.

Bonus Program: When employees identify a workplace hazard that could cause serious physical harm or a fatality, they are rewarded with a bonus check. In some cases, the bonus check is a fixed amount. In other programs, the bonus check is a very small percentage of the potential direct cost for the accident that might have occurred.

Safety Hero: After an extended period of time, employees are rewarded with a certificate, a day off, a gift card, or bonus for reporting hazards, making suggestion, or involvement in safety activities.

Reporting Injuries: Wait a minute: Do we really mean that employees should be recognized for reporting injuries? Absolutely. If employees report injuries immediately, they not only minimize the physical/psychological impact of the injury on themselves, they reduce the direct/indirect accident costs to the company. Both the individual and the company win if the employee reports injuries immediately.

Exception

Days Without an Accident: We do not consider this program effective because it promotes reactive - after the fact - behaviors: failing to report accidents and injuries. Actually, the "Days without an accident" banner reflects "Days without a reported injury." consequently, the company may suffer from the "walking wounded syndrome" in the workplace.

These are just a sample of many ideas available. There are many other ways to recognize employees being used by companies across the country.

For more information on developing a successful recognition program, take OSHAcademy course 117 Introduction to Safety Recognition.

8. Which of the following is a "reactive" safety recognition program?

a. Safety Hero Program
b. Days Without an Accident Program
c. Safety Bonus Program
d. Safety Buck Program

Check your Work

Read the material in each section to find the correct answer to each quiz question. After answering all the questions, click on the "Check Quiz Answers" button to grade your quiz and see your score. You will receive a message if you forgot to answer one of the questions. After clicking the button, the questions you missed will be listed below. You can correct any missed questions and check your answers again.

Video

Effective Meetings

Ever wanted to know how to run meetings effectively? This video explains 10 simple steps in having effective safety committee meetings.

Next Module

OSHAcademy Ultimate Guide Banner Ad